Republish
Undercover jailhouse stings have value. California shouldn’t abandon them
We love that you want to share our stories with your readers. Hundreds of publications republish our work on a regular basis.
All of the articles at CalMatters are available to republish for free, under the following conditions:
-
- Give prominent credit to our journalists: Credit our authors at the top of the article and any other byline areas of your publication. In the byline, we prefer āBy Author Name, CalMatters.ā If youāre republishing guest commentary (example) from CalMatters, in the byline, use āBy Author Name, Special for CalMatters.ā
-
- Credit CalMatters at the top of the story: At the top of the storyās text, include this copy: āThis story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.ā If you are republishing commentary, include this copy instead: āThis commentary was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.ā If youāre republishing in print, omit the second sentence on newsletter signups.
-
- Do not edit the article, including the headline, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and editorial style. For example, āyesterdayā can be changed to ālast week,ā and āAlameda Countyā to āAlameda County, Californiaā or āhere.ā
-
- If you add reporting that would help localize the article, include this copy in your story: āAdditional reporting by [Your Publication]ā and let us know at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- If you wish to translate the article, please contact us for approval at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations by CalMatters staff or shown as āfor CalMattersā may only be republished alongside the stories in which they originally appeared. For any other uses, please contact us for approval at visuals@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations from wire services like the Associated Press, Reuters, iStock are not free to republish.
-
- Do not sell our stories, and do not sell ads specifically against our stories. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page surrounded by ads you’ve already sold.
-
- Sharing a CalMatters story on social media? Please mention @CalMatters. We’re on X, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and BlueSky.
If youād like to regularly republish our stories, we have some other options available. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org if youāre interested.
Have other questions or special requests? Or do you have a great story to share about the impact of one of our stories on your audience? Weād love to hear from you. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org.
Undercover jailhouse stings have value. California shouldn’t abandon them
Share this:
Guest Commentary written by
Vern Pierson
Vern Pierson is the district attorney of El Dorado County. He is a past president of the California District Attorneys Association.
There is renewed scrutiny in California of so-called Perkins operations, the undercover jailhouse stings that let suspects speak freely to someone they believe is a fellow inmate. The scrutiny is fair, but a closer look shows Perkins operations are not the problem.
They remain lawful under U.S. and California Supreme Court precedent, and have helped resolve some of the stateās toughest cases, including gang shootings and cold-case homicides. The real issue is an interviewing culture that still leans on confrontation and deception long after research demonstrates those tactics unreliable.
A Perkins operation places an undercover officer beside a suspect who believes he is talking to a fellow inmate. Since the suspect does not know he is speaking with law enforcement, courts have long held these conversations do not trigger Miranda protections, which guard against the pressure of a known interrogation.
The Supreme Court settled this in its 1990 decision, Illinois v. Perkins, after investigators placed undercover officers in a cell with suspect Richard Perkins, who described a killing in detail after an agent asked if he had ever ādone anybody.ā The court held that Miranda addresses coercion created by a known interrogation room ā pressure that is absent when a suspect believes he is speaking to a peer, not police.
California courts have consistently followed that rationale.
People v. Zapata, decided this year, shows what happens when a Perkins operation crosses into aĀ legacy-style interrogation. The operation began within the bounds of Perkins: undercover officersĀ posed as inmates alongside Jason Zapata in a Riverside County holding cell. When Zapata stayed quiet, a uniformedĀ sheriffās deputy stepped in repeatedly to āstimulateā the conversation, and that is where theĀ operation changed character.
A Perkins operation works only because the suspect does not know he is talking to police. The moment a known, uniformed deputy inserted himself, it stopped resembling an inmate conversation and became the very thing the Miranda decision was written to check.
READ NEXT
‘Psychological warā: Inside Californiaās expanding use of jailhouse stings
The uniformed deputy then staged a fake lineup and falsely told Zapata a witness had identified him as the killer. Zapata, alone without a lawyer, asked for an attorney before discussing the murder. Instead of stopping, the uniformed deputy returned him to the cell, announced he was being charged with murder, and the undercover officers immediately resumed questioning him.
The Fourth District Court of Appeal found this created the same pressure as a direct interrogation, calling it a āpolice-dominated atmosphereā tainted by a known, uniformed officerās participation, and ruled the statements inadmissible.
Zapata does not show Perkins operations are flawed. It shows what happens when one stops being a Perkins operation at all. The moment the uniformed deputy took over and lied directly to Zapata, the encounter became an “old-fashioned interrogation” wearing Perkins operation clothing.
Concerns about coercion, reliability and secrecy trace back to one root: how interviews areĀ conducted in custody. Traditional interrogation tactics rely on fake lineups, polygraphs and false evidence ploys ā tactics that modern research shows degrade, not improve, information quality.
The answer is not to eliminate a lawful tool like Perkins operations. It is to modernize the culture that pushes officers toward heavy-handed tactics, and to keep undercover operations undercover, rather than letting known officers turn them into interrogations. Science-based interviewing, built on rapport and cognitive principles, consistently produce more reliable information.
Perkins operations have real value. But the future of trusted policing lies in science-based interviewing and a culture that respects rights, improves reliability and builds community trust, delivering justice for victims while upholding the Constitution.
READ NEXT
California may restrict undercover police operations targeting youth
5 things to know about undercover police stings in California jails