In summary

California politicians are vowing to do something about high gasoline prices but what remains very uncertain.

Call it, for lack of a better phrase, the “Gas Price Derangement Syndrome.”

Prices at the pump go up and down all the time, but when they take a sharp upward turn, motorists and the media take notice and like Pavlov’s dog, politicians shun responsibility and promise to do something about it.

The syndrome is particularly virulent in California because the state traditionally has the nation’s highest gas prices, largely due to high taxes and other unique factors.

The current spike, roughly $2 a gallon over the last two years, is running true to form. In 2019, when gas was about $4 a gallon, Gov. Gavin Newsom asked the California Energy Commission to investigate rising gas prices, mirroring a similar step by then-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2006.

The Energy Commission reported that, as any motorist knows, prices were notably higher at stations owned by major corporations than they were at independent stations. It raised the possibility of illegal price-fixing and Newsom asked the attorney general to investigate. That was two years ago, but no results have been announced.

Gas prices continued to rise, with the most recent spikes attributed to post-pandemic demand outstripping pandemic-constrained supply and sharp increases in the global oil market in the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

It is, however, an election year and politicians feel compelled to respond. This week, the speaker of the state Assembly, Anthony Rendon, created a special committee to investigate.

Learn more about legislators mentioned in this story

Anthony Rendon

Anthony Rendon

State Assembly, District 62 (Lakewood)

Anthony Rendon

State Assembly, District 62 (Lakewood)

How he voted 2021-2022
Liberal Conservative
District 62 Demographics

Voter Registration

Dem 57%
GOP 15%
No party 22%
Campaign Contributions

Asm. Anthony Rendon has taken at least $44,387 from the Finance, Insurance & Real Estate sector since he was elected to the legislature. That represents 12% of his total campaign contributions.

It’s not likely to be an objective inquiry since Rendon has already concluded that oil companies are engaged in “price gouging” and he wants the Legislature to “stand up to the profiteers who are abusing a historic situation to suck profits from California’s wallets.”

Meanwhile, Newsom, Rendon and other California politicians are pledging to offset the increase in gas prices with some kind of cash payments to Californians who have experienced not only pain at the pump but other sharp hikes in the cost of living. However, they disagree on how much to spend and how it should be distributed.

Republicans have been touting a suspension of California’s hefty fuel taxes for immediate relief. The state tax is now 51-cents a gallon, and it’s due to automatically increase by 3 cents on July 1. The GOP plan would not make a huge impact and has been rejected by Democrats who argue, with some validity, that oil companies might not pass on the cut to consumers.

Oddly, however, President Joe Biden is on the verge of asking Congress to suspend federal gas taxes, at 18-cents a gallon, and is demanding that oil companies ramp up production, thus seemingly putting himself at odds with fellow Democrats in California.

Truth is, the differential between California gas prices and those of other states has been studied in depth, particularly by Severin Borenstein, the state’s leading expert on the subject.

Borenstein, director of the Energy Institute at UC-Berkeley’s Haas School of Business, attributes the majority of the differential to California’s unique factors but in 2018, identified a “mystery surcharge” that was then about 22 cents a gallon.

That’s actually not surprising, given that the cost of doing business — any kind of business — is higher in California than almost anywhere else, which manifests itself in higher consumer prices of all kinds.

Maybe the latest investigations will turn up something that previous investigations and academic studies have missed. If they do, we’ll certainly see triumphant press conferences, but if not, they’ll just fade away until the next time Gas Price Derangement Syndrome takes hold.

We want to hear from you

Want to submit a guest commentary or reaction to an article we wrote? You can find our submission guidelines here. Please contact CalMatters with any commentary questions:

Dan Walters has been a journalist for more than 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times...