Republish
Calaveras County is a cautionary tale when California rural hospitals close maternity units
We love that you want to share our stories with your readers. Hundreds of publications republish our work on a regular basis.
All of the articles at CalMatters are available to republish for free, under the following conditions:
-
- Give prominent credit to our journalists: Credit our authors at the top of the article and any other byline areas of your publication. In the byline, we prefer “By Author Name, CalMatters.” If you’re republishing guest commentary (example) from CalMatters, in the byline, use “By Author Name, Special for CalMatters.”
-
- Credit CalMatters at the top of the story: At the top of the story’s text, include this copy: “This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.” If you are republishing commentary, include this copy instead: “This commentary was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.” If you’re republishing in print, omit the second sentence on newsletter signups.
-
- Do not edit the article, including the headline, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and editorial style. For example, “yesterday” can be changed to “last week,” and “Alameda County” to “Alameda County, California” or “here.”
-
- If you add reporting that would help localize the article, include this copy in your story: “Additional reporting by [Your Publication]” and let us know at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- If you wish to translate the article, please contact us for approval at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations by CalMatters staff or shown as “for CalMatters” may only be republished alongside the stories in which they originally appeared. For any other uses, please contact us for approval at visuals@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations from wire services like the Associated Press, Reuters, iStock are not free to republish.
-
- Do not sell our stories, and do not sell ads specifically against our stories. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page surrounded by ads you’ve already sold.
-
- Sharing a CalMatters story on social media? Please mention @CalMatters. We’re on X, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and BlueSky.
If you’d like to regularly republish our stories, we have some other options available. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org if you’re interested.
Have other questions or special requests? Or do you have a great story to share about the impact of one of our stories on your audience? We’d love to hear from you. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org.
Calaveras County is a cautionary tale when California rural hospitals close maternity units
Share this:
Guest Commentary written by
Maryal Concepcion
Dr. Maryal Concepcion is a family physician in Arnold and founder of My DPC Story, a podcast and education platform for doctors.
Health care officials recently decided Watsonville Community Hospital would close its maternity unit. Hospital leaders said the unit has lost the rural hospital about $10 million a year.
Also in late October, California’s Rural Health Policy Council met and discussed spending federal funds earmarked for rural health care.
People in both rooms should listen to what’s happened in a county that has made this trip already.
I am a family physician in Arnold, in Calaveras County, in the Sierra Nevada foothills. For the past 10 years, there has been no place to give birth here. My husband and I are the only physicians in the county who provide prenatal care, and we no longer deliver babies.
Here is what a decade without a hospital labor and delivery unit looks like: Pregnant patients with insurance are told to find care in another county. Some keep a particular health plan only so they can deliver at that plan’s hospital, more than two hours away.
Others plan to deliver in the next county over — if that hospital still accepts their insurance when the time comes. It hasn’t always.
Small tasks become long drives. Near the end of pregnancy, women must drive to another county to drop off urine samples, because there’s no longer a place near home to get blood or urine tested, unless you belong to one of the health system clinics there.
READ NEXT
Did Trump invest more money in rural California health ahead of the election?
Emergency service gets slower. When a pregnant woman calls my office because she can’t feel her baby move, I can see her, put an ultrasound on her belly and show her the heartbeat. A woman without that kind of access goes to urgent care — which is not reliably open on nights or weekends — and then to an emergency room, if she has a way to get there.
Skills leave with the ward. Ten years on, the nurses who knew how to help with a delivery have lost that practice. Nobody can say for certain that anesthesia is ready for an obstetric emergency.
There are no fill-in physicians who deliver and no backup plan, because there is no delivery service to back up.
Lastly, bringing maternity service back to an area is harder than keeping it.
I recently talked with someone who helped restore obstetrics in Plumas County. A community that wants it and has the money to pay for it is not enough, they told me. If the hospital’s leadership won’t come to the table, the effort stalls.
In my experience, that comes down to politics and dollars, not need.
My advice to Watsonville is to ask a different question than whether the unit loses money, because maternity does, almost everywhere.
The American Hospital Association counts 331 hospitals that have stopped offering obstetric care since 2010. In California, nearly 60 hospitals have stopped delivering babies since 2012, largely due to financial challenges and population decline in rural areas.
Ask instead: Once a maternity ward closes, who will be trained to care for a pregnant woman who arrives bleeding at 9 p.m.?
And 10 years from now, who will be left to bring it back?
California leaders should help directly fund the people still standing in counties like mine. Independent rural physicians, nurses and clinics carry pregnant patients through the gap a closed ward leaves behind. Make sure they can apply for this money, not only hospitals and health systems.
In Calaveras County, the answer to “who is left” is two family doctors. California can do better than that.
READ NEXT
Maternity ward closures in California result in much more than strained health care
She drove a hundred miles to give birth. New California laws are bringing maternity care closer to home