California is a wondrous place. I’m leaving

By Andrew Malcolm, Special to CalMatters

To me, California has always been an amazing place with a wondrous geography far more diverse than the other two largest states.

This helps explain why historically it has been such a beacon for so many Americans, including myself, seeking a golden future in the Golden State. But not just gold–oil, movies, entertainment, scenery, shipping, tourism, ag, music and more. For decades, Americans saw California as the country’s pioneering, trend-setting future, unless the Great Earthquake came in time.

It’s all here. Unfortunately, so are more people than reside in any other state. Which you’d think would be fine since California is three times larger than Iowa and 18 times larger than New Hampshire, the two states that we waste so much time talking about every four years.

But alas, about half of California’s 40 million have flocked into three metropolitan area—LA, San Diego and San Francisco.

As one result, for a variety of revealing reasons, several hundred-thousand Californians are fleeing the state annually, including me. A personal mantra has always been to run toward new jobs and homes, not flee old ones. Truth this time, we have many reasons to leave our Southern California home of 20 years.

I was talking with a neighbor this month as movers loaded his truck for Seattle. 

“California’s not the same anymore,” he said. 

He’s right. I lived in Illinois for many years, so I know one-party government well. Shortsighted Californian voters get what they elect—a loopy super-majority that lets billions in approved water bonds for reservoirs sit idle during an historic drought, so trillions of gallons of welcome rains flow to the ocean later.

But, by golly, they’re on top of the tiny shampoo bottle crisis. And forge ahead on the multi-billion dollar high-speed railroad for the countless thousands who want to get from Bakersfield to Merced quickly. And thanks to new legislation, Californians are finally free to legally reject any police officer’s plea for help.

L.A. County paid homeowners millions to tear out lawns to conserve water, apparently oblivious that every day every 600 square feet of grass produces oxygen for one person, fighting the smog the county must spend billions to ameliorate.

Then, there are taxes. California has the second highest gas tax at 61 cents, but the governor is working hard to catch up with Pennsylvania. Texas somehow survives with a 20-cent gas tax, Arizona with 19. 

Seven states, soon to be eight, have no income tax, including Nevada sitting temptingly next door.

“So you’re going to Tennessee too?” said our moving truck driver, a Texan now making regular trips from California to tax-free Texas, Tennessee and Florida. The other half of his load was also destined for the Volunteer state.

We traveled there earlier this year. Several things stuck out. Gas for $2.27 was a pleasant surprise. Bus drivers on a downtown loop greeted some passengers by name. 

Some fellow pedestrians said, “Hello.” And especially welcome, most every town has a Waffle House, which is like Denny’s without the sticky menus.

Learning the simplified property tax rules ($450 per $100,000 valuation) was encouraging.

We’ll miss the restaurant variety and some of the cultural events of urban California. 

But not the traffic trying to get there, the traffic trying to enter an affordable garage, not the lines of 5,000 others who wanted to be entertained, not the same people trying to leave later, nor the wait to exit the garage and the even longer wait while parked on the freeway. And we only spent $400 for the single evening’s experience.

California is indeed a special place. I’ve lived here by choice twice, nearly a quarter-century in total. The longest I’ve lived anywhere in 16 moves. 

I have no regrets about living here. And I don’t regret leaving here. As the neighbor said, “California’s not the same anymore.”


Andrew Malcolm is an author and foreign and national correspondent who’s lived in California this entire century, [email protected] He wrote this commentary for CalMatters.

Latest in Commentary



Dreamers have been political pawns for far too long

California recovery


California needs to create a just and equitable recovery

A woman pushes a cart past the shuttered Fox Theater in downtown Oakland on March 25, 2020. Today it was announced that Alameda, along with five area counties, would extend school closures through May 1 in an effort to limit the spread of COVID-19. Photo by Anne Wernikoff for CalMatters


It’s an easy decision to vote against tax increases on commercial property

California Capitol. Photo by Anne Wernikoff for CalMatters


Allowing Legislature to act more secretly

climate change


Entire 9th Circuit Court should hear climate change case brought by children

November election


Legislature needs to provide counties, voters with guidance on how Californians will be voting in November