Reader reaction: A dentist questions safety paradigms

This letter was written in response to A child’s death and the power of the dental lobby, which CALmatters published on April 13, 2016.

“There is no evidence that dental anesthesia under this model of care carries a greater risk than dental care with a second anesthesiologist present,” Alicia Malaby, spokeswoman for the California Dental Association (CDA), wrote in an email.

The CDA does not claim there is evidence that the single operator-anesthetist model is safe, only that there is no evidence that it is unsafe — a very different standard. Certainly very different than the standard it advocates when considering allowing dental therapists to operate in the state.

In 2012, when the California Senate was considering a proposal aimed at improving dental care for underserved children by, among other proposals, authorizing a project to explore new workforce training and delivery models such as dental therapists, the CDA’s support included its admonition that “A rigorous scientific study on the safety, quality and cost-effectiveness of allowing certain procedures, such as fillings, to be performed by non-dentists is needed. It is not appropriate for California to create any kind of provider without this assurance, and therefore CDA is opposed to any changes in scopes of practice until such compelling data exists.”

Apparently, the CDA feels the risk of therapists performing treatment under the supervision of dentists requires far greater verification of safety than the risk of dentists performing treatment while simultaneously administering and monitoring general anesthesia.

Does this approach accurately reflect the risk/benefit differences between these two paradigms?

Steven Krauss, DDS, MPH, MBA

Woodmere, NY

Latest in Housing

Larry Block owns Block Party, one of a handful of gay-owned and gay-centric shops left on Santa Monica Blvd. in West Hollywood. He’s lived in WeHo since 1985, but worries the neighborhood is going too mainstream. Photo by Elizabeth Aguilera for CalMatters


Gentrification is changing California’s iconic gay communities


California must not repeat old mistakes as it seeks new ways to end homelessness

Aerial shot of neighborhood.


California Legislature should recognize that housing is a right, not a Wall Street commodity


Housing crisis looms large

An aerAn aerial image of Portland, Oregon, which just passed significant rent control protections. Photo by Chronus via Wikimedia Commons.


Podcast: Oregon tenants did this to win renter protection—is California next?

The violent 1994 Northridge quake caused the collapse of the upper floor of the Northridge Meadows apartment complex, killing 16 people.


Podcast: Newsom wants to build 3.5 million homes—the very number a doomsday earthquake is forecast to damage