Republish
Why California courts need to pay low-income jurors more than $15 per day
We love that you want to share our stories with your readers. Hundreds of publications republish our work on a regular basis.
All of the articles at CalMatters are available to republish for free, under the following conditions:
-
- Give prominent credit to our journalists: Credit our authors at the top of the article and any other byline areas of your publication. In the byline, we prefer āBy Author Name, CalMatters.ā If youāre republishing guest commentary (example) from CalMatters, in the byline, use āBy Author Name, Special for CalMatters.ā
-
- Credit CalMatters at the top of the story: At the top of the storyās text, include this copy: āThis story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.ā If you are republishing commentary, include this copy instead: āThis commentary was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.ā If youāre republishing in print, omit the second sentence on newsletter signups.
-
- Do not edit the article, including the headline, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and editorial style. For example, āyesterdayā can be changed to ālast week,ā and āAlameda Countyā to āAlameda County, Californiaā or āhere.ā
-
- If you add reporting that would help localize the article, include this copy in your story: āAdditional reporting by [Your Publication]ā and let us know at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- If you wish to translate the article, please contact us for approval at republish@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations by CalMatters staff or shown as āfor CalMattersā may only be republished alongside the stories in which they originally appeared. For any other uses, please contact us for approval at visuals@calmatters.org.
-
- Photos and illustrations from wire services like the Associated Press, Reuters, iStock are not free to republish.
-
- Do not sell our stories, and do not sell ads specifically against our stories. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page surrounded by ads you’ve already sold.
-
- Sharing a CalMatters story on social media? Please mention @CalMatters. We’re on X, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and BlueSky.
If youād like to regularly republish our stories, we have some other options available. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org if youāre interested.
Have other questions or special requests? Or do you have a great story to share about the impact of one of our stories on your audience? Weād love to hear from you. Contact us at republish@calmatters.org.
Why California courts need to pay low-income jurors more than $15 per day
Share this:
Guest Commentary written by
Newton Lam
Newton Lam is a retired former deputy public defender, court commissioner and San Francisco Superior Court judge.
Trial by a jury of one’s peers is at the heart of our Constitution and our justice system. And yet, California fails to meet this requirement in courtrooms across the state. This is because our courts only compensate jurors $15 a day starting their second day of service, and they havenāt increased this amount in over 20 years.
In my extensive legal career as a deputy public defender and a San Francisco Superior Court judge, I was in the courtroom nearly every day. I witnessed firsthand the very real effects of our stateās meager compensation for jurors. All too often, higher-income jurors, who are often white, decide the fate of someone whose life circumstances are dramatically different from their own.
When I was a public defender and trial judge, I remember seeing prospective jurors walk in and think it was like all of San Francisco had walked into the courtroom ā an exhilarating mix of all the cityās neighborhoods. Unfortunately, after people with legitimate hardships were excused, the resulting jury was a selective sliver of city residents.
The good news is that California is very close to dramatically improving jury diversity, thanks to pending legislation. Assembly Bill 881, authored by San Francisco Assemblyman Phil Ting, overwhelmingly passed both houses of the state Legislature and now sits on Gov. Gavin Newsomās desk, waiting for his signature. If Newsom signs the bill, it will expand a program to raise juror pay for low-income jurors from $15 per day to $100 per day in San Francisco and four additional counties, rural and urban areas among them. The Judicial Council, which oversees the state’s court system, would choose the counties.
San Francisco piloted a similar initiative, which has shown remarkable results. Reports indicate the program has effectively reduced socioeconomic and racial disparities in juries and has strengthened participantsā trust in the legal system. I believe AB 881 will do the same. Like the San Francisco version, this bill has broad support statewide from public defenders and prosecutors alike.
Raising juror pay is long overdue. Californiaās jury pay is low compared to other states, despite our high cost of living. Other states are raising jury pay as well, with six states taking action this year alone. California hasnāt raised juror pay since the year 2000.
While a legislative analysis suggest the proposal could cost up to $9 million each year, the bill’s co-sponsors estimate the amount would be no more than $3 million annually, and it will only be implemented if the state appropriates funding for it. With fewer jurors being dismissed based on financial hardship, it will also take less time to secure enough jurors to start a trial, which will in turn reduce court expenses by an estimated $2.3 million.
Itās true that Legislators are in belt-tightening mode right now when it comes to the stateās budget. But $3 million is a modest sum compared to most state expenditures. And the benefits far outweigh the cost. This program will allow people who otherwise couldnāt participate in this sacred civic duty to do so ā people like my parents, whose jobs as a seamstress and grocer in Chinatown simply wouldnāt allow for them to take time off to be jurors. Ā
Public safety is improved when Californians trust that our justice system is meeting the needs of everyone in the courtroom. AB 881 benefits everyone impacted by our justice system.