Good morning, California. It’s Thursday, October 29. (Yes, I know I said it was September in yesterday’s newsletter; the pandemic has warped my sense of time.)

Traditional vs. progressive

Beyond the criminal justice propositions on California’s November ballot, the upcoming election will also serve as a barometer for the role Californians think district attorneys should play in the aftermath of historic protests against police brutality.

The main litmus test is taking place in Los Angeles County, with incumbent Jackie Lacey, a Democrat with a more traditional law-and-order approach, facing off against Democrat George Gascón, the former district attorney of San Francisco often described as a “progressive prosecutor.” In the wake of George Floyd’s death, Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti shifted his endorsement from Lacey to Gascón and U.S. Rep. Adam Schiff withdrew his endorsement of Lacey.

District attorneys, with the power to investigate and prosecute police killings, have come under renewed scrutiny for being too cozy with law enforcement. In June, a group of prosecutors — including Gascón — asked the state bar to ban district attorneys from accepting law enforcement money.

The political landscape also appears to be shifting in Alameda County, where District Attorney Nancy O’Malley recently announced she was reopening an investigation into a BART officer’s 2009 killing of Oscar Grant. The news came a few weeks after the Democrat became the second district attorney in the state to charge an officer for homicide under a new law restricting police use of deadly force.

Critics say O’Malley, long seen as a police ally, is attempting to head off a progressive challenger when she faces reelection in two years. 

  • O’Malley: “No matter what you do, someone’s going to criticize. So, for me, I have to do what’s right.” 

Someone considering a run against her: Assemblymember Rob Bonta. Last week, the Oakland Democrat unveiled plans to introduce a bill that would require district attorneys who have accepted law enforcement money to recuse themselves from investigations into officer misconduct. 

  • Bonta: “We must cure the conflict of interest that gives … the appearance that police officers are not being held accountable due to police unions’ direct campaign contributions to district attorneys.”


The coronavirus bottom line: As of 9 p.m. Wednesday night, California had 908,713 confirmed coronavirus cases and 17,475 deaths from the virus, according to a CalMatters tracker.

Also: CalMatters regularly updates this pandemic timeline tracking the state’s daily actions. And we’re tracking the state’s coronavirus hospitalizations by county.


1. California voters fear election unrest

Image via iStock

As Election Day inches nearer, 87% of California voters are concerned that many Americans won’t respect the outcome of the presidential election — and 88% think violence is likely if the outcome is in dispute, according to a Wednesday poll from UC Berkeley’s Institute of Governmental Studies. That marks a noticeable increase from September, when 82% of voters expressed doubt that Americans would respect the results of the presidential election. Meanwhile, 46% of voters said they were less confident mail-in ballots would be counted than votes cast in person — a view expressed by 78% of Trump supporters and 32% of Biden supporters.

  • IGS Co-director Eric Schickler: “The lack of public confidence that all votes will be counted and that both parties will respect the election outcome are worrisome signs of a political system that is under unusual stress.”

The news comes as some California police departments are gearing up for potential election-related unrest. The Beverly Hills Police Department recently announced plans to close Rodeo Drive on Nov. 3 and 4, and the Los Angeles Police Department told officers they may need to reschedule vacations originally booked during the week of the election.

2. Preview of prop votes

A raft of lawsuits insist California's attorney general writes proposition ballot labels and descriptions that are biased — but elections law allows a lot of leeway. Image via iStock
Image via iStock

Less than a week out from the election, 37% of California voters have already cast their ballots — and Democrats are voting early at much higher rates than Republicans or independents, a trend apparent in the results of an exit poll from Capitol Weekly released Wednesday. A majority of this left-leaning electorate expressed support for a number of statewide propositions that other polls indicate are close races or likely to fail. Here’s a closer look:

The Capitol Weekly poll also shows two measures losing by double digits — Prop. 20, which would crack down on crime, and Prop. 23, which would tighten regulations on kidney dialysis clinics. Losing by a few points: Prop. 19, another property tax measure, and Prop. 21, a rent control measure.

3. School reopening plans divide parents

A woman carries a sign in favor of reopening schools for in-person instruction during a demonstration in Brentwood on Sept. 15, 2020. Photo by Anne Wernikoff for CalMatters

California’s two largest school districts, Los Angeles Unified and San Diego Unified, don’t anticipate students returning to campus until January 2021 at the earliest, education leaders said this week. Predictably, the announcements stirred both support and vehement opposition from parents. Those criticizing the decision pointed out that other school districts in Los Angeles and San Diego counties have begun offering some in-person services to students.

  • LAUSD Board of Education Vice President Jackie Goldberg: “This is finals time for the high-schoolers and the end-of-semester assessments for all the other grades. Why would we want to go back in December? Which would probably be the earliest we could possibly go. … This is the wrong time to do that.”
  • Parent Danna Rosenthal: Any return is an improvement, “even if it means three weeks before the end of the semester. … My kids are suffering.”

Meanwhile, plans to reopen schools in Fresno County’s fourth-largest district spurred intense backlash along with fervent support at a heated board meeting this week.

  • Sanger Unified Superintendent Adela Jones: “I have never experienced in my 36 years of education a situation like this that has been so divisive. I do not want to see our community be divided over this.”

CalMatters commentary

CalMatters columnist Dan Walters: Three of California’s 12 statewide propositions renew sharp conflicts between business groups and unions.

College students must vote: Our generation has the ability to correct past mistakes and fundamentally shift the tone of American politics, argues Gabriella Sonderegger, a chemistry student at University of the Pacific.

Counties must invest in girls: When girls have nowhere to turn for safety or support, we perpetuate a cycle that leads to harmful outcomes for young people, write Desiree Victor of the Young Women’s Freedom Center and Haleema Bharoocha of the Alliance for Girls.

Other things worth your time

Firefighters gain control over Orange County blazes that forced 100,000 evacuations. // Los Angeles Times

How wildfires have driven an exodus from Butte County. // Mercury News

Need a translator to vote? California is trying to help. // CalMatters

Opinion: How California is failing Black women and girls exploited through sex trafficking. // Washington Post

An interview with anti-affirmative-action leader Ward Connerly. // EdSource

Why disaffection with Rep. Devin Nunes is growing among his constituents. // The Guardian

Reddit latest tech company to announce permanent work-from-home policy. // SF Gate

These tiny homes were going to solve Sacramento’s homeless crisis. So where are they? // Sacramento Bee

San Francisco to begin moving more than 500 homeless people out of hotels. Where will they go? // San Francisco Chronicle

See you tomorrow.

Tips, insight or feedback? Email

Follow me on Twitter: @emily_hoeven

Subscribe to CalMatters newsletters here.

Follow CalMatters on Facebook and Twitter.

CalMatters is now available in Spanish on TwitterFacebook and RSS.

Correction: This newsletter has been updated to reflect that Rep. Adam Schiff withdrew his endorsement of Lacey, rather than shifting it to Gascón.

We want to hear from you

Want to submit a guest commentary or reaction to an article we wrote? You can find our submission guidelines here. Please contact CalMatters with any commentary questions:

Emily Hoeven wrote the daily WhatMatters newsletter for three years at CalMatters . Her reporting, essays, and opinion columns have been published in San Francisco Weekly, the Deseret News, the San Francisco...